39 Comments

Another great piece. I feel kinda sorry for those men who are so rigid in their conception of masculinity that they're making themselves miserable when they don't have to.

Expand full comment

This is a great piece Michael, thanks. This guy's wife apparently kicked him out a few days before the incident so I'm reading a lot of the "men must be leaders" as "I am mad that I can't control my wife."

It seems like a LOT of men gauge their percieved masculinity on how many people they can repress. Women, minorities, non-cis/het people. Why so much need for dominance?

It's unfortunate that this guy BBQ'ed himself so thoroughly. It would have been interesting to see if he had CTE.

Expand full comment

I saw Bros open for Debbie Gibson in 1989 or so at the Roy Wilkins Auditorium. They cut their set short (I think they did one song) because they had “computer problems.” The mom next to me said “They seemed loud enough to me?”

Expand full comment

This needs to be a podcast … this could help young men deconstruct their toxic masculinity and counter act the right wing narrative

Expand full comment

dear michael,

super thoughtful piece.

i love the whole thing, especially the final paragraph:

"Men need help. They need support. But they also need a new vision of manhood, one that celebrates all the great things about traditional masculinity while embracing what is great about the undiscovered dimensions of ourselves, dimensions that are equally our birthrights: empathy, creativity, vulnerability. Women have spent the last sixty years figuring out how vast their own feminity can be. It’s long past time for men to do the same. Or they could just, you know, keep blowing shit up."

thank you for sharing!

love

myq

Expand full comment

John Kerry was CA a Vietnam war vet. That’s how he first came to public attention. He was also a thinker. He may be a good example of what a man should be—both active and intellectual.

Expand full comment

Excellent piece yet again. You are the perfect man and def my most butch friend.

Expand full comment

This is a wonderful piece.

Expand full comment

Confused he may have been, but let us give him credit and thanks for cutting out the middle bit of the performance, which is shooting a number of people before taking his own life, the stereotype ending of these scenarios.

I'd like this approach to catch on amongst others considering ending their lives in a blaze of protest. In that sense, Matthew was/is a role model.

Expand full comment

His other victim was that fine mech known as a cybertruck, which he successfully blew up before it could blow up itself

Expand full comment

This is so well written. It deserves to be read widely. So many men & boys would benefit from reading this.

Expand full comment

I wrote a book about it and, it turns out, men don't want to read about masculinity.

Expand full comment

I gave a copy of A Better Man to all my friends raising sons. If men won’t read it, at least moms can try to impart your wisdom to their sons.

Expand full comment

You have to meet them where they are seeking that conversation? Podcasts or videos, under the subscription model. Men tend to be visual learners, and a subscription model makes them feel elite.

Expand full comment

Not the target audience perhaps but I added it to my Goodreads. Thank you for reminding me that I need to read your books.

Expand full comment

Michael, bravo. Really, this one...bravo.

Expand full comment

Maybe you know this but Arnold Schwarzenegger’s newsletter is all about positive masculinity (and health) - I subscribe and read because it gives me hope to see men supporting each other in a positive way (and for the muscles)

Expand full comment

Susan Faludi wrote a book in the 90s called Stiffed. She focused on the WWII, Korean vets and their Boomer sons. What defined a man for these men and their male children. It's rather dated now since a couple of generations have grown up since, but for me to rung true. Masculinity took on a definition with expectations that were unachievable. I grasped the eccense of my father and my ex-husband in her analysis.

Being a modern male with the rapid socioeconomic changes in the late 20th and early 21st centuries had its challenges.

If you want to check it out from your library it was listed under male studies.

Expand full comment

Great post about an urgent issue. The best book I've read on this subject was written by Jungian analysts, oddly enough - "King, Warrior, Magician, Lover" (1991). It examines positive archetypes for masculinity as well as their shadowy toxic sides (eg. "King" vs. "Tyrant"). Highly recommended.

Expand full comment

Maybe there should be an anime adaptation

Expand full comment

Michael, I find your writing always insightful, and this piece particularly so. I hope that it finds its way to some of the bros.

Expand full comment

“ Women have spent the last sixty years figuring out how vast their own feminity can be.” 🫰 🫰(assuming this emoji means ‘coffee house poetry reading hipster finger snaps of affirmation’ and not something gross).

Expand full comment